Wonder what to fill your pierogi with? Here I have 15+ pierogi filling ideas for you! Everything from traditional pierogi fillings to more modern ideas.
What are pierogi?
Pierogi are one of the most popular Polish dishes (in Poland and abroad!). These polish dumplings are made with simple dough made with flour, hot water, and butter/oil, and filled with many different fillings. It’s the comfort food of every Pole!
I’ve seen people calling them pierogis, perogy, pyrogy, perogies, perogis, pierogies – yes! so many different versions. It’s much simpler in Poland – pierogi is the plural name of these delicious dumplings (so calling them pierogis makes no sense since ‘pierogi’ is already plural!) and 1 dumpling is 1 pieróg. You could also call them pierożki (this is how my daughter calls them!) which means literally ‘small pierogi’.
I will start with the pierogi dough since every pierogi recipe starts with the dough and this is a base for good pierogi! I like my pierogi dough rolled out thin and so tender that it melts in your mouth! Check out my very popular pierogi dough recipe, it has over 50 5-star ratings and many many comments from happy readers! In this post, you’ll find many helpful tips on how to cook and freeze pierogi, and also a video showing how to make pierogi.
#1 Pierogi ruskie (potato and cheese pierogi)
I will start with the most popular pierogi in Poland (at least in the region where I come from) and my personal favorite pierogi – pierogi ruskie. Pierogi ruskie (Ruthenian pierogi) are filled with Polish twaróg cheese (farmer’s cheese), sauteed onion, and mashed potatoes.
Here’s the recipe: pierogi ruskie.
#2 Potato and cheddar filling
This is an Americanized recipe for traditional polish potato and cheese pierogi, where you add cheddar cheese in place of polish twaróg cheese which is not easily available outside of Poland. I actually really like these pierogi, although they taste very different in comparison to the real potato and cheese pierogi. I added chopped rosemary and rosemary-infused butter to my recipe which makes it over the top delicious!
Here’s the recipe: potato and cheddar pierogi.
#3 Potato filling
This filling seems to be very popular abroad but it’s not really in Poland. You can make it with mashed potatoes and sauteed onion, season generously with salt and pepper.
#4 Sauerkraut and mushroom filling (pierogi z kapustą i grzybami)
This is my second favorite pierogi type! The recipe features cooked sauerkraut, sauteed onions and mushrooms (wild mushrooms and cremini mushrooms). These pierogi are really delicious, I usually make them for Christmas.
Here’s the recipe: Sauerkraut mushroom pierogi.
#5 Sweet cheese filling
My third favorite pierogi! The filling is made with Polish twaróg cheese (farmer’s cheese), sugar, and egg yolks. Yum!
Here’s the recipe: sweet cheese pierogi.
#6 Sauerkraut filling (pierogi z kapustą kiszoną)
Pierogi can be also filled with just sauerkraut, without the mushrooms. I don’t have that recipe yet but it will be surely posted in the future!
#7 Wild mushroom filling (pierogi z grzybami)
This filling is usually used to stuff uszka – little pierogi that are served with Christmas Eve Borscht soup (Barszcz czerwony/Barszcz wigilijny). The filling is made with wild porcini mushrooms and sauteed onions.
Here’s the recipe: uszka.
#8 Meat pierogi (pierogi z mięsem)
Meat filling is usually made from the meat leftover from rosół soup (meat broth). The meat is then put through a meat grinder and combined with sauteed onions, and sometimes mushrooms.
Here’s the recipe: meat pierogi.
#9 Dessert pierogi (fruit pierogi)
Sweet pierogi are filled with fruits. Any type of summer fruit can be used. The most popular fruit pierogi are blueberry pierogi, strawberry pierogi, and sweet cherry pierogi. You could also make a sour cherry filling, plum filling, black or red currant filling, blackberry filling, and farmer’s cheese filling. This filling is very simple, all you have to do is combine chopped fruits with sugar and flour, then fill the pierogi with the mixture – that’s it! (raw and not cooked fruits are used). In Poland, wild blueberries are used for blueberry pierogi – they are small blueberries that grow wildly in Polish forests. They are more flavorful than regular, bigger blueberries (which are actually called ‘American blueberries’ in Poland!). They are also more delicate and prone to breaking and staining your pierogi dough. Because of that, I like to freeze them first and fill the pierogi with frozen blueberries.
I recently got a comment from a reader, who made pierogi filled with apples. I think this is such a great idea and I plan to try them in the near future. Here’s the comment: “I cut some apples in small chunks, added raisins, butter, brown sugar, and cook till done. Filled each circle with 1 tsp. apples and when done sprinkled with confectionery sugar. They were amazing.”
Dessert pierogi are served with whipped cream or sweetened sour cream.
#10 Vegan pierogi with sun-dried tomato and lentil filling
This is not a traditional filling, but quite popular in Poland nowadays. The filling is made with sauteed onions with spices, red lentils and sun-dried tomatoes. These pierogi are really good! They can be made vegetarian if you’re using butter or vegan if you’re using vegetable oil.
Here’s the recipe: vegan pierogi with spicy sun-dried tomato and lentil filling.
#11 Buckwheat groats and farmer’s cheese (pierogi z kaszą gryczaną i twarogiem)
This filling is popular in the south-east region of Poland. It consists of cooked buckwheat groats (kasza gryczana) and Polish twaróg cheese. Sometimes also mushrooms are being add. You can substitute twaróg cheese with feta cheese.
If you’re wondering how to cook buckwheat groats, I have instructions here, in my buckwheat salad recipe.
#12 Smoked cheese (oscypek) and cranberry jam
I haven’t tried this pierogi filling but it’s very high on my ‘to-do’ list! I’ve found this video of a popular cook – Jamie Oliver, you can see the video here. The filling is made with oscypek (Polish cheese), cranberry jam, mashed potatoes, cottage cheese, cream, and onions.
This filling is not traditional but it’s inspired by a traditional street food that is very popular in Zakopane – a city in the south of Poland. Oscypek with cranberry jam is being sold on every street of this city, it’s very very delicious.
Oscypek is the name of a traditional polish cheese that comes from the Tatra Mountains region of Poland. It’s smoked sheep’s cheese. It’s usually sold in a traditional oval shape, it’s firm and squeaky (similar to Halloumi cheese). There is probably a very small chance that you can find this cheese outside of Poland, so you can substitute it with any other smoked sheep’s cheese or just smoked cheese like smoked gouda, smoked cheddar, or smoked mozzarella or scamorza cheese.
#13 Spinach pierogi
Pierogi filled with spinach are quite popular right now in Poland, but this is not a traditional recipe that my grandma would make. This particular filling is my invention and it’s made with spinach, potatoes, onions, and feta cheese. So, so delicious!
Also, the color of these pierogi is not photoshopped! The dough is colored with beet juice and it really is so pink. I like to make these pierogi for Christmas – they look so beautiful and Christmassy!
Here’s the recipe: Spinach pierogi.
You could also make a similar filling – with spinach and ricotta. You could use the same filling that is used to filled pasta shells.
#14 Pumpkin filling
Pumpkin filling? why not! You could say that pumpkin is not a Polish vegetable, and it’s true, both of my grandmas haven’t cooked anything with pumpkin but nowadays it is a very popular vegetable, available in every grocery store. Poles don’t make pumpkin pie but pumpkin soup or pumpkin muffins are quite popular. I’ve also seen pierogi filled with pumpkin, either with sweet filling (roasted pumpkin/butternut squash + pumpkin pie spice + sugar) or savory pumpkin filling (similar to ravioli filling) with pumpkin and parmesan cheese, served with sage butter.
#15 Chanterelle mushroom filling
Chanterelles mushrooms are one of the most beloved Polish mushrooms (my favorite mushrooms!). They are widely used in anything from chanterelle sauce, to pasta dishes or soup. I especially like scrambled eggs with chanterelle mushrooms!
To make chanterelle mushroom filling, cook the mushrooms with onions and garlic, season generously with salt, and pepper, then chop in a food processor.
#16 Poppy seed, dried fruit, and honey
This filling is similar to the poppy seed roll filling (makowiec). These pierogi are served just for Christmas Eve.
#17 Some other pierogi filling recipes that I find interesting
Mushroom, potato, and caramelized onions
What to serve with pierogi?
Actually pierogi in Poland are usually served on their own!
The most popular toppings include:
- melted butter
- sour cream
- crispy bacon
- caramelized onions
- skwarki – fried pork backfat
- sweetened sour cream or whipped cream for sweet pierogi
Here you’ll find all my pierogi sauces and toppings ideas.
Dear readers! If you’ve come up with some delicious pierogi filling ideas, make sure to leave me a comment and I will add them to the list!
Nelle Maltese16 February 2023 at 17:41
Thanks for sharing such a great helping infomation.
April Dunbar16 January 2023 at 03:22
Thanks for all this info … my Mom made pierogi quite often and she gave me her method before she died. My daughters and I are trying to replicate it. She took a head of cabbage and cut it several wedges then boiled it to partially cook it, then chop it into small pieces. She would chop an onion and fry it in her cast iron skillet in butter. When the onions were softened she would add the chopped cabbage with salt and pepper to fully cook the filling. She used eggs in her dough but I’m going to try your version to compare. I love these and miss my Mom! Her mother was Polish and her dad was Hungarian. I’ve looked for cabbage recipe versions a lot…. Thanks!
Amanda27 December 2022 at 23:48
There is a few on your list I’d love to try. I’ve always experimented on mixes. We do Pizza, parm& garlic, and smoked Gouda with ghost pepper. They are all really good. My family on my moms side would always get together at Xmas and grandmas birthday to make them. She has since past on but I still continue to do make them because it brings back so many memories
Aleksandra28 December 2022 at 15:41
thank you, these fillings sound very interesting!
William Makarevich15 July 2022 at 14:51
My wife makes kimchi pierogi that is wonderful. I don’t know the recipe, but it would be similar to making a sauerkraut pierogi but substitute the sauerkraut with Korean kimchi.
Aleksandra15 July 2022 at 18:23
what a great idea! thank you for sharing!
Susanne17 April 2022 at 05:58
Can you use frozen berries for these?
Aleksandra17 April 2022 at 06:35
yes, if you have small pieces of fruit such as blueberries you don’t need to thaw them, but for bigger pieces such as strawberries I would thaw them, cut into smaller pieces, and toss them with corn starch and sugar
Janice29 March 2022 at 06:00
A neighbor of mine introduced me to fish as a filling. She would use a local fish, Northern Pike, and would cook it then add potatoes and seasonings. She was surprised I had never heard of it. She had lived about an hour away and said it was common in her area.
Aleksandra29 March 2022 at 18:01
Yery interesting, I will definitely try that! I saw salmon filling recipes on the internet but haven’t tried it yet.
Sharon10 January 2022 at 04:18
I make cabbage pierogi. Shred cabbage fine, sauté with butter til brown. These are my husbands favorite. I also make ricotta cheese. One container of ricotta cheese mixed with an egg yolk, 2 tablespoons of sugar, and a dash of cinnamon.
Aleksandra10 January 2022 at 10:12
that sounds delicious, thank you for sharing!
William Makarevich15 July 2022 at 14:55
If your husband likes spicy food, you can try substituting cabbage with Korean Kimchi. My wife makes them and it is one of my favorites.
Mary Jane Sample22 December 2021 at 14:41
After my parents passing, I now am the Matriarch of the family. Traditional fillings weren’t always my favorite. I prefer the Americanized versions using cheddar cheese as the base and then adding ingredients.
Potato/cheddar/onion w/sausage&Portabella mushrooms
Potato/onion w/ Horseradish Cheddar
Potato/cheddar/onion w/ ham & broccoli
Lobster w/ butter
My Fruit filled ones I make with cream cheese added and sugar in the dough, fried and then doused with Confectionery sugar!!
Aleksandra22 December 2021 at 14:59
wow, so many great options! thank you so much for sharing!
John M9 December 2021 at 21:15
The classic pierogi in my family was kapusta. Canned rinsed sauerkraut (which makes it considerably less salty) was briefly steamed in a pan with soft sautéed onions, flecks of ham, and a fair amount of black pepper, to be used as a filling. For unknown reasons, these pierogis were always preferred to mashed potato, or cheese, or prune-filled pierogis.
I plan to make Impossible burger filling for our celebrations with my son and his family this Xmas.
I have used a cheap plastic asian dumpling press that I got over ten years ago. It works quite well.
Aleksandra9 December 2021 at 21:25
thank you for sharing!
Corrine17 January 2022 at 05:51
Vegan burger filling? What is your recipe, if uiu don’t mind sharing…..
Rita Frank19 November 2021 at 23:33
I make Sweet potatoe/orange/Yams mixed with white potatoes onions
dill and salt and pepper. They are delicious.
Aleksandra20 November 2021 at 08:46
such a great idea, thank you!
william Krochak15 August 2021 at 00:28
I use potato water, an egg, pre-sifted flour, salt, olive oil, and my Cuisinart to mix the flour that becomes very soft dough. I wrap it in Cling Wrap, cover it with a cloth, and let it rest in the refrigerator for 1hour. I like using Yukon Gold Potatoes, salt, unsalted butter, Spanish Onion sauteed in butter, and medium cheddar cheese for the filling. One other very important ingredient is love. I love making this dish. It is labor intensive. Eating them is the best part with button mushrooms, and sprinkled with more onions that are fried in butter and sour cream. Tea is the beverage in memory of my dad who always had tea when my mom made them. Good cooking!
Tanya6 June 2021 at 02:34
My grandmother used farmer’s cheese, onion, green onion tops, salt, pepper, and eggs. Those are the only ones I like. Since she passed my mom and I make them but don’t have access to fresh farmer’s cheese anymore due to the lady’s cow died. Trying to find a recipe to make the cheese ourselves.
Charlotte6 October 2021 at 16:14
I don’t know where you live, but here in New York state (and some other states) you can get fresh farmer’s cheese at Wegmans
Theresa15 April 2021 at 19:28
My mother and grandmother made a filling with mashed potatoes and cottage cheese then pan fried the pierogis in butter and onion. So good!!
Alison Libby13 April 2021 at 13:12
Years ago at a Pierogi making get together, I am sure the filling was cabbage, onion and polish sausage. Does that sound familiar? Would you just cook up the minced ingredients in butter? I have never been able to find a filling recipe like this.
Aleksandra13 April 2021 at 14:17
I haven’t eaten this kind of pierogi, but I’ve seen something similar – with kielbasa, sauteed cabbage, onions, and sauerkraut. If you want to make the filling with just cabbage, onion, and sausage, I would do it like this: heat oil in a pan, cut kielbasa into slices and brown in a pan, then add diced onion and cook until soft, transfer to a plate, then sautee thinly sliced cabbage until soft (you should add water to the pan from time to time, the cabbage should stew at the beginning and at the end of cooking time when all the water has evaporated, pan-fry it, it should be golden and caramelized). Chop everything roughly with a knife or in a food processor (but not too fine), season with salt, pepper, marjoram, thyme, and a little bit of paprika, then fill the pierogi with the filling. If you’d like to add sauerkraut to that, you need to cook it for about 30-45 mins, until softened. I hope it will turn out well!
Dorothy4 April 2021 at 04:19
love the filling with sauteed fresh cabbage and onions; hadly can find them anywhere. Some places say the filling is too time consuming to make. I don’t think so.
Aleksandra4 April 2021 at 05:55
sounds lovely, thank you for sharing!
Jim R1 April 2021 at 16:07
My Grandmother and Mother traditionally made pierogi every year for easter. It has now fallen on me to make them for the whole family. My wife’s favorite filling is Ricotta cheese – one container of ricotta mixed with 1 egg, 2 tablespoons of sugar (or 3!) , and 1/2 teaspoon of vanilla.
Aleksandra1 April 2021 at 17:48
Thank you so much for sharing!
Stan Komenda2 April 2022 at 18:13
My grandmother would put prunes and mashed potatoes for filling. I was only 5yrs old but I do remember.
victoria kelsey29 March 2021 at 14:39
My Mother always made a mashed potato, sauteed onion, sauerkraut pierogi. It’s one of my favorites.
Aleksandra29 March 2021 at 17:15
sounds delicious! thank you for sharing!
Rachael16 February 2022 at 21:17
We usually have those at Thanksgiving and Christmas and Easter. We do potato and cheddar, saurkraut and onion (use the tart kraut and saute with onions, and my dad like the prune. I would love to try the apple pie one. Sweet potato sounds good with maybe brown sugar cinnamon maple with a marshmallow . We drown ours in salted butter. Day olds are fried in a pan for breakfast or brunch. My husband likes the with mustard
Aleksandra16 February 2022 at 21:21
thank you for sharing, very interesting!